Props/clothing that you like?

TLDR
I've been exactly where you are - a drawer full of teddies, one rabbit I secretly hated looking at, and sets that all started feeling like the same shoot with different lighting. The fix wasn't spending more money; it was buying differently and rotating what I had. Here's how I'd audit your setup today.
What lingerie actually adds visual range beyond teddies?
Teddies have one silhouette. That's the whole problem - your camera sees the same shape every shoot no matter the color. The pieces that fight that: bodysuits (they read differently front-on versus a teddy because of the torso coverage), garter sets with contrast - think black bandage against sheer panel - fishnet, and anything with a tulle or sheer layer floating over skin. Latex or vinyl is worth one piece if your audience leans edgier, because nothing photographs like a shiny surface catching light. You don't need ten new sets. You need maybe four that each look like a *different* aesthetic: one sheer, one garter, one textured (fishnet or lace with gates), one structured/bodysuit. That alone doubles how varied your catalog looks.
How do you choose outerwear that upgrades a shot?
Outerwear works because what's covered creates tension. A robe left half open, an oversized button-down sliding off one shoulder, a leather jacket over nothing - all of these sell more than the lingerie fully displayed. When you're shopping, ignore color first and think about texture: satin slides and reflects, faux fur eats light and looks lush, a wool coat reads moody. Robes and kimonos are the highest-value buys because they're adjustable mid-shot - open, closed, slipping - which gives you three outfits in one. If you only grab one thing from this section, make it a long robe in a dark color.
Which toys are worth the money, and what about the ugly rabbit?
Here's my honest ranking. A realistic dildo earned its "must-have" reputation for a lot of cam performers because it reads clearly on camera and viewers respond to it - but "for a lot of performers" isn't "for everyone." If your crowd shows you they love it, it's your workhorse; don't retire it. The rabbit situation is the interesting one. Your instinct is right: if a toy is ugly to *you*, you'll underuse it, your camera energy drops, and it shows. You don't have to force it. Two options: keep it as a video-only tool where you can cut around it, or sell/donate it and replace it with a similarly-shaped toy you actually like looking at. For shot variety, insertable variety matters more than toy count - different sizes and silhouettes give different framing options per set.
What misc props keep sets from feeling repetitive?
Lube and cosmetics are your baseline. The cheap wins are: a pair of heels or boots (changes the whole body line), a mirror (free new angles), a silk scarf or tie - bondage-adjacent but sellable in SFW clips - bedding swaps (a different sheet color resets an entire room), and if you want to go further, shower/oil setups or a food item for themed content. None of these need to cost much. The point is that one small object plus your existing lingerie equals a set that looks brand new.
How do you keep every purchase paying for itself?
Before buying anything, plan three shots it could appear in. If you can't, skip it. Then set a simple rotation: theme of the week - sheer week, robe week, boots week - and one prop audit per month where you list what you own and note what hasn't been used. Buy only when the audit exposes a real gap, not when you're bored on a Wednesday night. That habit fixed my repetition problem more than any single purchase did. And if live shows are where your income actually lives, it's worth pairing this system with a platform built for them - XLoveCam is my recommendation for performers who want steady traffic to point all this styling work at.
Ready to make your next set feel new?
Your inventory is probably better than you think - it's just under-styled. One outerwear layer, one texture upgrade, and a weekly theme will wake it up before you spend real money. So here's the question to sit with: which single item in your drawer, if you only owned it, would make every future set harder - and what's stopping you from shooting that first?